Slow-cooked buffalo and mushroom pies

Few things beat a homemade meat pie, especially when it’s filled with tender, slow-cooked game meat. Naturally lean and full of character, buffalo is a delicious alternative to beef, with its robust taste standing up beautifully to earthy mushrooms and a rich, savoury gravy. It takes a little patience, but the reward is a batch of golden, hearty pies that are well worth the wait.

Serves: 4-5
Duration: 7 hours

Ingredients

  • Buffalo backstrap cut to fit in a 12V Travel Buddy oven
  • 1 pack low salt French onion soup mix
  • 2 punnets of Swiss brown mushrooms
  • Plain flour or gravy powder
  • Fresh garlic
  • 1 small onion
  • Salt and pepper
  • Red wine – optional.

Method

  1. Pie maker – cut shortcrust pastry sheets to size for the base and puff pastry sheets for the top. Use sesame seeds if you want to be fancy.
  2. Put the raw meat (from room temperature) in an oven bag with a pack of French onion soup mix. No need to add any liquid. Pre-heat the Travel Buddy (or similar) to 95°C and cook the buffalo for six hours, turning once to keep the meat sitting in natural liquid.
  3. Pour the meat and liquid into a large mixing bowl. Take the meat out and pull apart. Remove all fat and cut across the grain in 1.5cm slices so it can be pulled apart. Put the shredded meat into the mixing bowl.
  4. Gently brown the cut onion and cook down the sliced mushrooms with some butter and garlic, with a bit of salt and pepper to taste.
  5. Combine the meat and mushrooms/onions. Thicken any sloppy mix with flour or gravy powder. Add salt, pepper or even a dash of red wine to taste.
  6. Follow the pie maker directions, cool on a rack and serve with Sriracha Ketchup.

Related
Articles

THDRS28H-angle-1
| ,

First hunt with the ZeroTech Thrive HD Reflex

My M6 Scout survival rifle has been a trusty companion on my journey as a licenced…
20240410074325 enhanced
| ,

When the fallow rut doesn’t go to plan

I had done all the physical scouting I could do. Mentally I'd run a checklist through…
Pic 2D page
|

Inside John Rigby’s rifle revival

Mention the name of London gunmakers John Rigby & Co. and visions of adventures in far-off…
Image 8-2
| , ,

A mixed bag: Cats, foxes and hares

It’s funny how things work out. My dad has been home brewing beer for as long…
9 enhanced
| ,

.338 RUM and .416 Ruger for big game

Some years ago, while preparing for a hunting trip to Canada, I began evaluating various calibres…
Knife, rifle and deer hide
| ,

What to look for in a hunting knife

As long as we humans have hunted for meat, there has been a need for the…

Related
Recipes

Biltong 1
|

Biltong-inspired venison strips

Biltong is a salted and spiced dried meat product that originated in South Africa. This easy…
Photo 01
|

Venison, rosemary & garlic sausages

After a successful venison hunt, prime trimmings are ideal for mincing and can be put to…
Photo 02-2-2 enhanced
|

Classic venison stroganoff

Venison is ideal for stroganoff - a simple but rich recipe that’s a hearty meal and…
VJ 05 2
|

Smoky venison jerky

A good supply of lean fallow venison provided the perfect opportunity to experiment with homemade jerky.…
Moroccan slow cooked camel
|

Moroccan slow-cooked camel

Camel is a lean, flavoursome meat with a firm texture that benefits from slow cooking. This…
IMG_1824
|

Field hare pie

Hare's rich flavour and firm texture make it ideal for slow cooking. Topped with golden mashed…